NJ's Best Italian - Mangia! Mangia! - These are our top 38 Picks! Bon Appetit

Our choice for one of the top Italian restaurants in the State. Scalini Fedeli has been on top ten lists for the best Italian in its class for many years. This is your choice if you want to impress a date or if you want to celebrate a special occasion with loved ones or friends. This is mainly because of it's extraordinary gorgeous intim... Read More

Sapori Trattoria is definitely one of the best Italian restaurants in NJ. This South Jersey favorite specializes in some of the most authentic Italian cuisine one can find in the United States. All dishes are prepared with the freshest ingredients and follow many of the old-world recipes you might find in Italy. Additionally, if you don't see a dish that ... Read More

If you are looking for an Italian restaurant in NJ with an old-fashioned and inviting atmosphere, visit La Fiamma Restaurant in Harrison. This restaurant boasts about their homemade dishes, including linguini with clam sauce, gnocchi, mixed vegetable dishes and a penne with vodka sauce that is to die for. They even have a children's menu with options such... Read More

One of Atlantic City NJ's best Italian restaurants is Chef Vola's. This small family owned restaurant makes everything from scratch and strives to give every patron the Italian dish of their dreams. In addition to the native Italian entrees, you will also find a variety of Italian American inspired dishes such as veal and chicken parmigiana, ravioli, crab... Read More

Founded on the principle "eat local, drink global," Eno Terra combines cuisine crafted from locally-sourced ingredients with the best wines from around the world. This Italian restaurant in Middlesex County NJ only uses produce from local farms or the season harvest from their own Eno Terra Canal farm. Additionally, patrons can be assured that they only u... Read More

At this Italian restaurant in Northern NJ's Hudson County, you can expect to find classic dishes with a twist. Anthony David's Gourmet Specialties boasts about their menu, which is unlike any other you have seen before. They feature less common meal options such as wild boar ragu, squid ink linguine, lamb sausage, and even truffle risotto! This is the bes... Read More

If you are looking for the best Italian food in Essex County NJ, stop by Porto Leggero. This restaurant only serves authentic Italian dishes, offering both traditional dishes such as spaghetti, veal, grilled lamb and even shrimp scampi and signature dishes including rigatoni gorgonzola, slow-roasted lamb shank, pan-roasted salmon and much more! While enj... Read More

Undici Taverna Rustica in Rumson, NJ only uses fresh produce, fish and meat, all delivered on a daily basis because they want to ensure that their patrons are served the freshest and most delicious dishes. Their menu is complete with something for everyone. They have pizza, antipasto, a variety of pasta dishes and authentic Italian entrees such as branzin... Read More

Family owned and operated since 1990, Assaggini Di Roma serves delectable traditional Italian cuisine with attention to detail to make an intimate dining experience. For some of the best Italian food in Hazlet, NJ this is the perfect spot for a night out or the perfect venue for your next event up to 100 patrons.... Read More

With perfect Italian dishes, Patricia's of Holmdel offers a fine dining experience perfect of an intimate meal and also equipped to accommodate large events, Patricias of Holmdel is one of the top Italian Restaurants in Monmouth County NJ. A BYOB Italian Restaurant dedicated to bringing you delicious meals with great service this restaurant serves delicious... Read More

Right in the center downtown Rutherford Paisano's is a family-owned and operated fine dining establishment making their dishes with only the freshest ingredients and thoughtfully prepared recipes it is the perfect Italian restaurant for every Italian food aficionado. ... Read More

With handcrafted northern Italian cuisine and a friendly atmosphere, Justin's Ristorante makes you feel right at home from the moment you walk through the door. With an extensive menu of delicious choices, there is sure to be something for everyone when you sit down in this BYOB restaurant. With packages for parties in their private party room, they can ... Read More

From delicious handcrafted pizzas and delicious dinner and lunch options, Lubranos 36 is considered by residents to be a taste of Tuscany right here in Middletown NJ. With a high emphasis on customer service and providing an upscale dining experience in an approachable and affordable setting Lubrano's 36 is highly reviewed and recommended by the local commun... Read More

Established in 1996 Girasole Cucina Italiana has been serving traditional Italian dishes with a modern flair. Considered to be one of the best Italian restaurants in Somerset County their goal is to create an authentic Italian experience in an elegant settin... Read More

Vidalia Restaurant offers an intimate dining experience that provides the perfect atmosphere, food, and service. For over ten years Chef Salvatore Scarlata has been creating contemporary Italian food and inventive dishes with a personal touch, prepared with love for the food and the patrons... Read More

This small quaint restaurant is considered by many to be the best Italian spot in Hudson County. Family owned and operated they provide traditional Italian food as well as a number of other dishes that you can't find anywhere else. Be sure to make a reservation ahead of time because the seats at Augustinos Kitchen and Bar fill up fast and stay filled with fo... Read More

Founded by native Naples, Italy resident Andrea Covino in 2012 Andrea Trattoria Italiana has been satisfying customers from all around with their classic Italian recipes. With a menu that features traditional fare from Naples, Italy and in a true trattoria style, Andrea Trattoria Italiana is a family-run restaurant located in the heart of Millville NJ.Read More

It is said that eating at Salute is a lot like going to a friend's house for dinner. With an open kitchen, you will be captivated by the aromas that find your table as you wait for your meal to arrive. Diners are encouraged to bring their favorite wines to pair with the dishes served at Salute to give you a truly authentic Italian dining experience. Read More

Family owned and operated, Jozanna's is a casual Italian restaurant in Middlesex, New Jersey that features some really exceptional great food in a comfortable atmosphere. Jozanna's is also known for you being able to BYOB and their attention to detail when it comes to customer service. With great food prepared daily using only the freshest ingredients J... Read More

Recently restored and reopened, Espo's Restaurant & Bar is quickly re-establishing itself as a staple of true casual Italian cuisine in Raritan, New Jersey. Providing a great place for drinks and dinner, Espo's has all of the traditional flairs of a really expensive Italian restaurant with a modern feel at very affordable prices. It's a perfect date nig... Read More

This is one of our top choices in this area for Italian. We highly suggest that you go for the Vicana salad, which comprises of grilled chicken red onion, tomatoes, avocados, fresh mozzarella balls, and an amazing dressing. Our other top choice. Their Bolognese is our go-to als... Read More

If you are just passing by Robbinsville or if you are local Ravello by Toscano is a must stop Italian restaurant in Mercer County, New Jersey. Open for lunches and dinner Ravello also has takeout as well. From handcrafted pizza to traditional Italian dishes, like chicken and veal parm as well as delicious sandwiches, Ravello's lunch menu is a great choic... Read More

For a traditional (and way above average) American Italian dining experience in Mercerville, New Jersey Mamma Rosa's Restaurant is the place for you. Mamma Rosa's is run and operated by the D'Amelio family. Mamma Rosa's specializes in tomato pie style pizza and pan pizza, but that's not all they do. You can get a number of Vitello (veal) dishes, hot and... Read More

Since 1990 Lunello has been serving innovative Italian dishes in a fine dining atmosphere. Using out of the ordinary ingredients, homemade pasta, and innovative specials, Lunello has created a loyal following that keeps coming back for more. The menu features Italian classics as well as modern specialties using only the finest and freshest local ingredie... Read More

A staple of the Montclair community for over thirteen years, Fascino is a modern Italian restaurant run by Chef Ryan DePersio. With a comfortable and elegant atmosphere, Fascino is a must stop for any Italian food aficionado. Fascino Italian Restaurant has a menu consisting of innovative dishes and choices that are not found anywhere else in the state.<... Read More

Using old school recipes, Cafe 2825 is an upscale dining experience that will make you feel like you are in New York's Little Italy. With a full bar and an extensive wine list, this is the perfect place for any Italian food lover. Specializing in regional Italian foods and serving only the freshest fish, steaks and chops as well as homemade risotto and ... Read More

Founded in 2011, Zeppoli is a small and intimate location serving up to 35 tables in a romantic setting. Take it from us, this is the perfect place for a date night. With the option to BYOB to pair your favorite wines with their unique menu, Zeppoli's a perfect place to make unforgettable memories among friends and lovers. Zeppoli serves classic yet si... Read More

When you step into Sapore Italian Restaurant it is like stepping into the past in rustic Italy. With Trip Advisor's certificate of excellence in both 2016 and 2017, it is a great place to relax and eat phenomenal food in a beautiful setting. Rated the best restaurant in West Cape May, this BYOB Italian restaurant has a delicious dish for everyone. From... Read More

Villaggio Iccara uses traditional Italian recipes with a contemporary flair. They believe food is a connector to the roots of family and old traditions. For over 22 years Villaggio Iccara has been creating an intimate experience that they take pride in, and it shows in their dishes. Serving both lunch and dinner Villaggio Iccara's menu is as diverse as ... Read More

Opened in 1939, Chick and Nello's Homestead has a loyal following of dedicated clientele. They have been roasting meats over a wooden grill using traditional Italian methods for a long time. Although they claim that "The Homestead has never had a menu." They serve up delicious meats on their wood grill like Rib Eye Steak, T-bone Porter House Steaks, Home... Read More

Bringing a modern Mediterranean flair to traditional Italian recipes, Bottagra Restaurant is a very unique eatery in Northern New Jersey. Offering a variety of dishes from both Northern and Southern Italy, the Bottagras menu is sure to satisfy even the pickiest Italian food lovers. In the Bottagra restaurants classic New York City-style dining rooms you ... Read More

Italian Touch Restaurant and Pizza in Cranbury, NJ is one of our picks for one of the best casual pizzeria-style restaurants you can go for Italian food in Middlesex County. While they have plenty of dishes that are to die for, the one dish that the restaurant boasts about is their stuffed eggplant. Expertly prepared and served as either... Read More