Here are The Top 43 Restaurants, Bars, and Pizzerias (of 2024) Where You Can Get The Best Pizza in NJ | It's Time to Try A Slice of Heaven!

Yo, if you're hankering for the best 'za in the Garden State, peep this fire list of the top 41 joints that are serving up some serious pie game! Here it is! The unadulterated list of the best pizza in NJ | The True List

There's a reason NJ is said to have some of the best pizza, compared only to New York. Try it for yourself to believe it. For your convenience, we have compiled a list of all the best places to grab a slice. Use it as your culinary guide as you explore different exquisite combinations of dough, tomato, cheese, and olive oil. Take it one step further and have a bite of a unique pie including anything from toppings such as Chorizo or caramelized pecans to Ramen or even taco pizza. Once you go NJ pizza, you'll never go back. Once you realize that this is the #1 unrivaled go-to guide of NJ pizza, you'll keep coming back for more! Who has the best pizza in the world? New Jersey of course!

This List of the Best Pizza in NJ is Not in any Particular Order

Bobby Flay has recently endorsed Razza as one of his favorites in New Jersey.

Close

Razza

  201-356-9348 | Hudson County

Jersey City, New Jersey

Best Pizza in NJ

Razza has surely met the expectations of true artisanal wood fire pizza making in the North Jersey region! Their Buratta pizza is made with fresh Buratta, fresh tomatoes, garlic, basil, and freshly made dough. The crust is perfectly crisp, slightly charred and the dough has just the right consistency. This is probably one of the best pizza's we have ever... Read More

Visit Website View Details

Marcello's makes an amazing Tomato Pie! Tell Chuck the pizza maker that Charlie from FunNewJersey.com sent you!

 

Marcello's Coal Fired Restaurant and Pizza

  609-298-8360 | Burlington County

Bordentown, New Jersey

Best Pizza in NJ

This is one of the top pizza places in NJ. As a matter of fact, this is one of our top 3 overall picks for the Trenton area for tomato pies. Located in the lovely town of Bordentown. The bar is very handsome and all of their food is really spectacular. But if you're going to come, come for the pie... Read More

Visit Website View Details

Vic's Italian American Restaurant

  732-774-8225 | Monmouth County

Bradley Beach, New Jersey

Best Pizza in NJ

As a local favorite, it is not uncommon to see Vic's packed on weekend nights. Not only is their pizza the perfect medium between soft and crispy, but their drink selection is incredible! Vic's has pizza geared towards a more traditional crowd as well as contemporary, and you can customize it as well. You will leave Vic's satisfied, full of delicious pizza a... Read More

Visit Website View Details

Federici's Family Italian Restaurant

  732-462-1312 | Monmouth County

Freehold, New Jersey

Best Pizza in NJ

Federici's is a long-standing, family business specializing in thin-crust-pizza. There are more varieties of pizza than you can dream of from their specialty pizzas to their classics. If that's not your speed, there are a number of homemade Italian dishes you are sure to enjo... Read More

Visit Website View Details

Kate and Al's

  609-267-1147 | Burlington County

Columbus, New Jersey

Best Pizza in NJ

Right in the local Farmer's Market, Kate and Al's serves delicious square pizza. Loaded with sauce and cheese on a crunchy crust, it is sure to satisfy your pizza needs! Customize it with your own toppings or get it plain, they provide you with plenty of options that are sure to make everyone happy... Read More

Visit Website View Details

Nomad Pizza Hopewell

  609-466-6623 | Mercer County

Hopewell, New Jersey

Best Pizza in NJ

Nomad's is the up and coming pizza place for artisanal personal pies you could only dream of. With only the freshest local ingredients, this pizza will not disappoint! There are also plenty of unique flavor combinations to choose from. To stray from the traditional pizza place, visit Nomad's in Hopewell. N... Read More

Visit Website View Details

Maruca's Tomato Pies

  732-793-0707 | Ocean County

Seaside Heights, New Jersey

Best Pizza in NJ

Maruca's is praised by locals as being one of the pizza pies down by the shore. The tomato sauce swirled atop the pie gives it a signature look that is always associated with Maruca's. You can customize your pizza or delve into their menu for something different such as a sandwich or pasta dish... Read More

Visit Website View Details

De Lorenzo's Tomato Pies

  609-341-8480 | Mercer County

Trenton, New Jersey

Best Pizza in NJ

De Lorenzo's provides its customers with fresh and unique ingredients. Choose from the classics such as basil, artichokes, mushrooms, or opt for something like their clam or tuna tomato pizza pie. They also cut their pizza in any shape you request, not necessarily slices. Whatever you are looking for, De Lorenzo's will cater to those needs in a delicious wa... Read More

Visit Website View Details

For artisanal lovers, this is the best New Jersey pizza spot to hit up!

 

Tino's Artisan Pizza Co.

  609-688-0007 | Middlesex County

Kingston, New Jersey

Best Pizza in NJ

For authentic dishes in a terra cotta cooking style, visit Tino's Artisan Pizza Co. for your dinner out! With organic ingredients and signature styles, it's no wonder Osteria Procaccini has gained a high reputation among locals. Come by today to test out some traditional as well as specialty terra cotta pizza... Read More

Visit Website View Details

Pete and Elda's

  732-774-6010 | Monmouth County

Neptune City, New Jersey

Best Pizza in NJ

If you favor thin crust pizza, Pete and Elda's is the perfect place for you! They specialize in crisp thin crust pies that you customize to your liking. Locals adore it and people from all over Monmouth County come to taste a slice of their pie... Read More

Visit Website View Details

Santillo's Brick Oven Pizza

  908-354-1887 | Union County

Elizabeth, New Jersey

Best Pizza in NJ

Santillo's Brick Oven Pizza offers up pies of the perfect texture and ratio of soft to crispy. You can also choose whether you want a French bread, extra thin, Sicilian or traditional crust depending on whether your preference. This is perfect for a group who just can't get along on what the best type of pizza crust is. Eat it your way at Santillo'... Read More

Visit Website View Details

Joey's Pizza is best known for their Brooklyn style and Old Fashioned tomato pies.

Joey's Pizza Of Hamilton

  609-585-3500 | Mercer County

Trenton, New Jersey

Best Pizza in NJ

Joey's of Hamilton is absolutely one of our top 3 choices for the best tomato pies in the Trenton area. They blend a secret cheese with the mozzarella and then pair that with the freshest tasting (sweetest) pizza sauce that we have ever had. Joey's Pizza also, serves fish plates, wraps, pasta, calzones, Stromboli, chicken, and veal dishes. But trust us... Read More

Visit Website View Details

Papa's Tomato Pies is the second oldest restaurant in the nation!

Close

Papa's Tomato Pies

  609-208-0006 | Mercer County

Robbinsville, New Jersey

Best Pizza in NJ

Papa's Tomato Pies was founded in 1912, is the second oldest (arguably the first) pizza restaurant in the entire nation. The tomato pies are absolute perfection and they rank in our top 3 as our unofficial choice of the best tomato pies in the Trenton area. They are well known for their high quality, old school friendly atmosphere, and extremely reasona... Read More

Visit Website View Details

Gennaro's Italian Restaurant and Tomato Pies is one of the best restaurants in the Trenton/Hamilton area.

Gennaro's Italian Restaurant and Tomato Pies

  609-587-4992 | Mercer County

Hamilton, New Jersey

Best Pizza in NJ

Gennaro's a lovely casual restaurant, that serves Tomato Pies and top-notch Old World Italian cuisine. They offer an awesome full menu featuring only the finest, freshest, local seasonal ingredients. Gennaro's has an outside dining area that has boasts both a romantic vibe and a family-friendly atmosphere. We recommend Gennaro's as making one of the be... Read More

Visit Website View Details

Brooklyn Square is well known for its Upside Down Square Pie. If you bever had a Brooklyn style square pie, come here and try perfection. It will change everything you thought you knew about pizza!

Brooklyn Square Pizza

  732-851-7599 | Monmouth County

Manalapan, New Jersey

Best Pizza in NJ

One of our top picks in Central New Jersey. They have a few pies that are worth tying, But when it comes down to it, it is all about the Brooklyn Square Pizza. This is one of the best Brooklyn style pies we have ever tasted. Located near the Englishtown Auction. Come out and give it a try!... Read More

Visit Website View Details

Bricco Coal Fired Pizza uses one of the world's most expensive ovens.

Bricco Coal Fired Pizza

  856-477-2233 | Camden County

Westmont, New Jersey

Best Pizza in NJ

Owner Vincenzo Barone created Bricco's Coal Fired Pizza because he wanted to enlighten his customers of the lost art of making pizza. His goal was simple. To use only the freshest ingredients. His passion and attention to detail of the preparation and cooking is very evident when you taste his pizza. Their dough is aged, brought to the proper temperatur... Read More

Visit Website View Details

Porto's is well-known for the excellence of its true artisanal pizzas!

Close

Porto By Antonio

  201-941-7101 | Hudson County

North Bergen, New Jersey

Best Pizza in NJ

Porto's is best known for the excellence of its food, Neapolitan artisanal pies, and service. Come try their super fresh airy bubbly crust with the topping of your choice. Every single one of their pizzas is truly amazing. This sot has to be in the top 10 of all of New Jersey for Neapolitan style pizza. Porto also serves a full selection of wines, beers... Read More

Visit Website View Details

Anthony's has an awesome huge sliding glass window in the storefront by the bar, that opens up to let the wind and sun in on the restaurant.

Close

Anthony's Coal Fired Marlboro

  732-780-2625 | Monmouth County

Englishtown, New Jersey

Best Pizza in NJ

Anthony's is the place to go to if you want to grab a pot of meatballs to go, or to get a perfectly cooked pizza pie. Their pies from their coal ovens are absolutely delicious and trend-setting for the local area. They handpick their tomatoes from Italy every year and they are proud to boast that they do not have freezers or fryers. They have a very nic... Read More

Visit Website View Details

As far as Taverns and pizza goes, Kinchleys Tavern gets our pick for the "Best Bang for your Buck", and "Best Thin Crust Pizza" in North Jersey."

Close

Kinchley's Tavern

  201-934-7777 | Bergen County

Ramsey, New Jersey

Best Pizza in NJ

Kinchley's Tavern in Ramsey NJ has been a favorite amongst locals since 1937. Kinchley's boasts Bergen County's number one award-winning ultra-thin crust pizza. Kinchley's offers a casual family-friendly setting along with a full menu and featuring 10 taps flowing with a rotating selection of seasonal and regional brews. This is one old school establish... Read More

Visit Website View Details

Tony Boloney's

  609-344-8669 | Atlantic County

Atlantic City, New Jersey

Best Pizza in NJ

Despite Tony Boloney's expansive menu, they have gained popularity among locals for their pizza made from their very own yeast! They offer a number of classic and specialty pizzas, including their taco pizza, with tacos lining the rim and fresh guacamole in the center! Don't miss out on their one-of-a-kind pie... Read More

Visit Website View Details

The Absolute Best Pizza NJ | Here Are Some More Editorial Picks To Add To The True List!

Here are some more of our favorite pizzerias in the Garden State

Aquila Pizza Al Forno
7A Paterson Ave, Little Falls, NJ 07424
973-256-0050
Aquila offers up wood-fired pizza. All ingredients are made fresh and in-house. They make their own pizza dough and mozzarella. If you are looking for Neapolitan light and airy type of dough, it should be on your bucket list. The restaurant is BYOB and they take cash only.

Denino's Pizza Place
Aberdeen Township
The OG of the OG's, this place has been slinging some of the best 'za in Jersey since 1933, and they ain't stoppin' anytime soon.
 

Nunzio’s
521 Raritan St., Sayreville, NJ 08872
732-727-1060 
Come for the thin crust Margherita Pizza Fina. Also, come for the pizza by the slice overstuffed options at lunchtime.

Santillo's Brick Oven Pizza
639 S Broad St. Elizabeth, NJ 07202
908-354-1887
Authentic thin-crust pizza with a one-of-a-kind sweet tomato sauce. Santillo's was opened back in 1918. Worth the drive for a thin-crust Sicilian, pepperoni bread or the 18-inch 1957 style super thin pizza with sausage and mushrooms! They have about 10 other different pizza styles from different eras including ones from 1940, 1960, 1990, and 2011. 

Two Top Choices from Asbury!

Porta
911 Kingsley St, Asbury Park, NJ 07712
732-776-7661
Boasting some of the best pizza down the Jersey shore. Porta was also voted for one of the best brunch spots on Sunday and Monday until 4 PM.

Talula's
550 Cookman Ave. #108 Asbury Park, NJ
732-455-3003
Try one of their signature pies, The Beekeeper’s Lament which is lusciously topped with fresh tomato sauce, mozzarella, hot Calabrian soppressata, and local honey.

Here are some Top Picks of the Best Tomato Pies in the Hamilton NJ area!

Papa's Tomato Pies 
19 Robbinsville Allentown Road, Robbinsville, NJ 08691
609-208-0006
(Also listed above as a featured listing)
The oldest family-run pizza joint in NJ (and the entire USA) has one of the best tomato pies we have ever tasted. Papa's is also famous for its reasonably priced oversized portions of chicken parm, linguini with clams, and spaghetti and meatballs.

Joey’s Pizza of Hamilton
201 Whitehorse Mercerville Rd. Trenton, NJ 08619
Phone:(609) 585-3500
(Also listed above as a featured listing)
The secret is in the cheese. Joey's Pizza uses more than one cheese and trust us, it makes all the difference in the world! This is in our top 10 of the best pizza in all of NJ!

Palermo's
674 US Highway 206, Bordentown, NJ 08505
609-298-6771
Get a large Tomato Pie with extra garlic and a chopped antipasto salad!

DeLorenzo's Tomato Pies
2350 NJ-33 Robbinsville, NJ, 08691
609-341-8480
Known for it's very thin and perfectly crisp pies cut into small diagonal squares. This is a well known local Robbinsville institution when it comes to tomato pies. DeLorenzo's also serves some amazing salads. Try the Chopped Antipasti which feeds 3 people easily and boasts salami, asiago cheese, Italian tuna, artichokes, olives, and long hot peppers.

Thin and Greasy Pies to Die For

General Saloon
1194 Englishtown Road, Old Bridge, NJ 08857
732-416-8628
Perfect greasy thin pizza. It's everything that you could hope for when you are drinking cold ones at the bar. Did we mention trying a pie with pepperoni or sausage and peppers (our two favorite combinations) which again, are both very thin and perfectly greasy?

Vic's Italian Restaurant 
60 Main St, Bradley Beach, Monmouth County, New Jersey 07720
732-774-8225
(Also listed above as a featured listing)
A true New Jersey Institution. Thin authentic greasy pies that you must experience at least 10 times in your life.

Conte’s Princeton
1194 Englishtown Road, Old Bridge, NJ 08857
732-416-8628
Another true legendary institution serving extra thin crispy crust, semi-greasy pizza with just the right amount of zip in their sauce!

ARTIE'S
Maplewood
A no-frills joint that's been dishing out some serious 'za for decades, and their pizza game is on point.

The Best Pizza in New Jersey Does Not Stop Here! These are Some More Good Really Gourmet Pizzerias and Restaurants Who Have The Best Pizza

Aquila Pizza
Little Falls NJ

Una Pizza Napoletana
Atlantic Highlands

These Picks are More of a Traditional Pizzaria Style Pie

Novino Ristorante
Mahwah

Benny Tudino's
Hoboken

Tony D's Pizza
Caldwell

Calabria Restaurant & Pizzeria
Livingston

Rosie's Pizza
Point Pleasant

 
Squan Tavern
Manasquan

A Quick History of New Jersey Pizza 

The history of pizza in New Jersey can be traced back to the early 1900s when Italian immigrants started to arrive in the Garden State. When they got here, some experienced pizza makers started opening up never seen before pizzerias. These early pizzerias were essentially located in areas where there were predominantly Italian populations, such as Jersey City, Newark, and Trenton.

The first know pizza place in NJ was Joe's Tomato Pie located in Trenton. Joe's opened its doors in 1910.

Papa's Tomato Pies (which opened its doors in 1912) is the oldest surviving pizzeria and restaurant that is still in operation until this day.

One can speculate that Papa's (among a few others) was the first to create one of the (now) most well-known styles of pizza in New Jersey which is called "Tomato Pie" or the "Trenton pie". The tomato pie is a specific type of pizza where the cheese is placed directly on the dough first and then the sauce is placed on top. The sauce was fresh, uncooked, simple (without a lot of ingredients to let the tomato shine and a little sweet. Some tomato pie barks dust the pie lightly with freshly grated parmesan cheese before cooking.

One of the oldest thin crust style pizzeria restaurants is the family-owned Federici's in Freehold NJ which has been making marvelous unique one-of-kind thin crust pizzas for over 100 years.

Over time, the popularity of pizza spread like wildfire throughout the state, and today there are one or two (or more) pizzerias in just about every single town in New Jersey.

Another famous style of pizza believed to have originated in Sicily, that has been said to have been first brought to New Jersey is the "Sicilian pizza" which is a large, square-shaped pizza that is typically made with a thick, doughy crust and topped with a variety of ingredients, including tomato sauce, cheese, and meats.

Overall, pizza is an important part of New Jersey's cultural heritage, and it continues to be a beloved food among residents and visitors alike.

What Makes NJ Pizza so Good?

Pizza is basically the superhero of the New Jersey food world, and here's why:

The CRUST: A good NJ pizza crust is has the solid foundation of top level flour and NJ water! Our pizza crust is crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside, and provides the perfect canvas for all the other delicious ingredients.

The SAUCE: I talians that migrated to the Garden state know a a few things about making sauce! A quality pizza sauce adds a punch of flavor and helps bring everything together.

The CHEESE: It's the cheese that makes pizza so addictive, man. That gooey, stretchy goodness melts in your mouth and is the perfect complement to the sauce and crust.

The TOPPINGS: The sky's the limit when it comes to pizza toppings, from classic pepperoni and sausage to more adventurous options like pineapple and barbecue chicken. You can customize it to your heart's content.

Pair Your Pie With A Beer!

There's no better delight to your taste buds than a refreshing and bubbly sip of beer after a warm and cheesy bite of pizza. The balance of warm and cold, gooey and crisp, makes for the perfect pairing. Taste some of the best bar pies NJ has to offer. If beer isn't your speed, don't worry. The full-service bar offers cocktails, mixed, drinks, wine, and more!